• Elite stars like Josh Allen and Lamar Jackson set a high standard, showing why mental toughness is key in NFL Week 1 quarterback performance.
• Young QBs showed potential but faced challenges, with turnovers often proving costly in tight games.
• Veterans leaned on experience to navigate team struggles, proving the value of solid support like offensive lines.
• Week 1 revealed how adaptability under pressure shapes early-season narratives for quarterbacks.
• Readers will gain insights into early trends, perfect for fantasy football picks or betting strategies.

Navigating the Pressure of NFL Week 1 Quarterback Performance

Having covered NFL seasons for years, I know Week 1 is like stepping into a spotlight with no rehearsal—every quarterback’s move gets magnified. This year’s opener, highlighted by Josh Allen and Lamar Jackson’s epic Sunday Night Football duel, set the tone for evaluating NFL Week 1 quarterback performance. 

At Bleacher Report, we’re grading based on poise, decision-making, and game impact, using these elite performances as the benchmark. It’s like a chef’s first dish at a new restaurant—you get one shot to impress, but small tweaks can lead to a masterpiece.

Breaking Down the Best and the Bumpy Starts

Kyler Murray Battles Through for Arizona Cardinals

In a hard-fought 20-13 win over the New Orleans Saints, Kyler Murray overcame illness and five sacks, completing 21 of 29 passes for 163 yards and two touchdowns, plus 38 rushing yards. His connection with Marvin Harrison Jr. laid a foundation for Arizona’s offense. While more fireworks are expected, this gritty NFL Week 1 quarterback performance deserves praise for securing the win. Grade: B

Michael Penix Jr. Shines in Atlanta Falcons’ Close Loss

Despite a 23-20 loss to Tampa Bay, Michael Penix Jr.’s NFL Week 1 quarterback performance turned heads, with 27 of 42 passes for 298 yards, a touchdown pass, and a rushing score. Baker Mayfield even tipped his hat, praising Penix’s decisiveness. He needs to polish his touch on layered throws, but his potential is clear. Grade: B

Lamar Jackson’s Brilliance Stifled in Ravens’ Collapse

Baltimore led big before falling 41-40 to Buffalo. Lamar Jackson’s NFL Week 1 quarterback performance was stellar—14 of 19 for 209 yards, two TDs, plus 70 rushing yards and a score—but late conservative playcalling limited him. As he noted, games aren’t over until the clock hits zero. Grade: A-

Josh Allen’s Historic Heroics Lift Buffalo Bills

Trailing by 15 late, Josh Allen’s NFL Week 1 quarterback performance was legendary, throwing 33 of 46 for 394 yards and two TDs, plus two rushing scores in a 41-40 comeback win. He made history with 250+ passing yards and two rushing TDs in one quarter, per OptaStats. With a 1.1% win probability, per NFL Next Gen Stats, Allen proved his clutch. Grade: A+++

Bryce Young’s Struggles Persist for Carolina Panthers

Carolina’s 26-10 loss to Jacksonville saw Bryce Young go 18 of 35 for 154 yards, one TD, two picks, and a fumble. He’s more poised than last year, but accuracy issues linger. His focus on self-improvement is a good sign, but results need to follow. Grade: D

Caleb Williams Shows Flashes for Chicago Bears

In a 27-24 loss to Minnesota, Caleb Williams hit 21 of 35 for 210 yards, a TD pass, and a rushing score. His raw talent shines, but overthrows and late reads stalled drives. It’s like driving a high-powered car—control comes with experience. Grade: C

Joe Burrow Underwhelms in Bengals’ Narrow Win

Cincinnati’s 21-20 win over Cleveland was ugly, with Joe Burrow’s 14 of 23 for 113 yards and a TD dragging in the second half—minus-18 yards in the fourth quarter, per Jay Morrison. Missed kicks saved them, as Burrow admitted they “stole one.” Grade: D

Joe Flacco Keeps Browns in the Fight

In that 21-20 loss, Joe Flacco threw 31 of 45 for 290 yards, one TD, and two tipped picks. At 40, he needs more help from receivers and the run game to elevate Cleveland’s offense. Grade: B

Dak Prescott Stays Steady for Dallas Cowboys

Dallas fell 24-20 to Philadelphia, but Dak Prescott’s 21 of 34 for 188 yards held firm despite CeeDee Lamb’s drops. His poise amid chaos suggests brighter days if the team steps up. Grade: A

Bo Nix Relies on Defense in Broncos’ Win

Denver’s 20-12 win over Tennessee saw Bo Nix struggle, throwing 25 of 40 for 176 yards, a TD, two picks, and a fumble. Turnovers and low efficiency won’t cut it long-term, as he acknowledged. Grade: F

Jared Goff Adjusts to Lions’ New Look

In a 27-13 loss to Green Bay, Jared Goff’s 31 of 39 for 225 yards, one TD, and a pick showed rust with new coordinators. Red-zone struggles need addressing. Grade: C

Jordan Love Controls Green Bay Packers’ Offense

Green Bay’s 27-13 win over Detroit featured Jordan Love’s 16 of 22 for 188 yards and two TDs, spreading passes to 10 targets. His command against blitzes sets a high bar. Grade: A

C.J. Stroud Faces Uphill Battle for Texans

Houston’s 14-9 loss to the Rams saw C.J. Stroud go 19 of 27 for 188 yards with a pick. Rebuilding chemistry is tough, but as leader, he must drive the tempo. Grade: C

Daniel Jones Lights Up Indianapolis Colts’ Offense

Indy’s 33-8 rout of Miami showcased Daniel Jones’ 22 of 29 for 272 yards, a TD pass, and two rushing scores. Scoring on every possession, per NFL Communications, proves his fit. Grade: A+

Trevor Lawrence Finds His Groove for Jaguars

In a 26-10 win over Carolina, Trevor Lawrence’s 19 of 31 for 178 yards, one TD, and a pick benefited from a clean pocket and strong run game. His Clemson poise is back. Grade: B

Patrick Mahomes Fights On for Chiefs

Kansas City’s 27-21 loss to the Chargers didn’t dim Patrick Mahomes’ 24 of 39 for 258 yards, a TD pass, and a rushing score. Line and receiver issues persist—he needs support. Grade: B

Geno Smith Ignites Raiders’ Passing Game

Las Vegas’ 20-13 win over New England saw Geno Smith throw 24 of 34 for 363 yards, a TD, and a pick. Nine deep completions despite turmoil? That’s veteran grit. Grade: A-

Justin Herbert Powers Chargers’ Upset

In a 27-21 win over Kansas City, Justin Herbert’s 25 of 34 for 318 yards and three TDs, plus 32 rushing yards, broke the Chiefs’ division streak. He’s elite. Grade: A

Matthew Stafford Defies Doubts for Rams

The Rams’ 14-9 win over Houston featured Matthew Stafford’s 21 of 29 for 245 yards and a TD. Spreading passes beyond Nacua will unlock more wins. Grade: B

Tua Tagovailoa Falters for Miami Dolphins

Miami’s 33-8 loss to Indy saw Tua Tagovailoa’s 14 of 23 for 114 yards, a TD, two picks, and a fumble yield a 2.7 QBR. Turnovers and confusion crushed them. Grade: F

J.J. McCarthy Rallies Vikings in Debut

Minnesota’s 27-25 win over Chicago featured J.J. McCarthy’s 13 of 20 for 143 yards, two TDs, a pick, and a rushing score. Three fourth-quarter TDs, per Real Sports, mark a bold start. Grade: B

Drake Maye Shows Potential in Patriots’ Loss

New England’s 20-13 loss to Las Vegas saw Drake Maye’s 30 of 46 for 287 yards, a TD, and a pick. Inconsistencies linger, but flashes hint at growth. Grade: D+

Spencer Rattler Stabilizes Saints’ Offense

In a 20-13 loss to Arizona, Spencer Rattler’s 27 of 46 for 214 yards and 29 rushing yards was clean—no turnovers. He nearly tied it late, showing promise. Grade: B

Russell Wilson Stumbles for Giants

The Giants’ 21-6 loss to Washington saw Russell Wilson’s 17 of 37 for 168 yards lack impact. Leading in rushes isn’t enough; he’s on thin ice. Grade: F

Justin Fields Sparks Jets’ Attack

In a 34-32 loss to Pittsburgh, Justin Fields’ 16 of 22 for 218 yards, a TD pass, and two rushing scores showed efficiency. He’s a dynamic threat. Grade: A-

Jalen Hurts Proves Critics Wrong for Eagles

Philly’s 24-20 win over Dallas featured Jalen Hurts’ 19 of 23 for 152 yards, plus 62 rushing yards and two TDs. A +15.2% completion rate, per NFL Next Gen Stats, seals his value. Grade: A

Aaron Rodgers Shines in Steelers’ Revenge

Pittsburgh’s 34-32 win over the Jets saw Aaron Rodgers throw 22 of 30 for 244 yards and four TDs. At 41, he’s still got it, spreading scores to four targets. Grade: A

Brock Purdy’s Late Magic Saves 49ers

In a 17-13 win over Seattle, Brock Purdy’s 26 of 35 for 277 yards, two TDs, and two picks ended with clutch plays despite injuries. That’s a winner’s mentality. Grade: C+

Sam Darnold’s Errors Hurt Seahawks

Seattle’s 17-13 loss to San Francisco saw Sam Darnold’s 16 of 23 for 150 yards undone by a late fumble. Over-reliance on one receiver needs work. Grade: C

Baker Mayfield’s Clutch Drive Lifts Buccaneers

Tampa Bay’s 23-20 win over Atlanta saw Baker Mayfield’s 17 of 32 for 167 yards and three TDs, plus 39 rushing yards. A game-winning drive shows his growth. Grade: B+

Cam Ward Faces Tough Debut for Titans

Tennessee’s 20-12 loss to Denver saw rookie Cam Ward’s 12 of 28 for 112 yards and a fumble hurt by six sacks. A steep learning curve, as his coach noted. Grade: D

Jayden Daniels Gets It Done for Commanders

Washington’s 21-6 win over the Giants saw Jayden Daniels’ 19 of 30 for 233 yards, a TD pass, and 68 rushing yards. Sloppy but effective, with room to grow. Grade: C+

Reflecting on NFL Week 1 Quarterback Performance

Week 1 is like the first lap of a race—some drivers surge ahead, others spin out, but everyone’s learning the track. From my vantage point, covering games and crunching stats, the quarterbacks who stood out weren’t just the ones piling up yards. 

It was the ones who stayed cool under pressure, like Allen turning a near-loss into history, or McCarthy flipping a rough debut into a win. For fans, fantasy players, or anyone tracking the NFL, these early performances hint at who’s building momentum and who’s got work to do. Keep watching—these stories are just beginning to unfold.

Related articles:
NFL Week 1 Takeaways 2025
Ravens NFL History Week 1
2025 NFL Week 1 Injury Report
Cowboys vs. Eagles Week 1 Winners and Losers
2025 NFL Power Rankings

Aliha

Hi, I’m Aliha! I’ve been a huge NFL fan for as long as I can remember, and I love sharing my thoughts, updates, and insights about the game. Whether it’s big plays, team news, or behind-the-scenes stories, writing about the NFL gives me a chance to connect with fellow fans who share the same passion for football.